Sen. Whitehouse-Schatz's Save Our Future Act Provisions To Respect Environmental Justice Concerns

Average Rating:

By Jerry Hinkle, CCL Research Coordinator

b34506cbc6ac4fbc18c1e630e23b5d52-huge-snThe Save Our Future Act (SOFA), introduced in June by Senators Whitehouse and Schatz and summarized here, is a type of carbon fee and dividend (CFD) legislation that includes strong provisions to reduce harmful air pollutants in frontline communities (see page 39 of the bill). It returns significant funds to frontline communities, as well as to American families in general, in order to support economic growth and to offset climate damages. The purpose of this analysis is to explore the potential impact of the bill's Environmental Justice (EJ) provisions.

Any carbon pricing policy is expected to rapidly reduce air pollution in local communities. However, this bill attempts to further address the concern of the disproportionate impact of harmful air pollution on those most vulnerable. Specifically, it places a charge on criteria air pollutants SO2,NOx andPM2.5 when they are emitted from a “major source” within one mile of an Environmental Justice Community. The charges are $18.00, $6.30 and $38.90 per pound of the pollutant, respectively.

According to the EPA, total annual US emissions of SO2 (here), NOx (here) and PM2.5 (here) were 1.96, 8.23, and 5.64 million short tons (2,000 pounds/ton), respectively, in 2020. We do not have estimates at this point as to what proportion of these would be covered by the legislation, but presume here that combined emissions from fuel combustion, industrial processes, and waste management & recycling may serve as a useful proxy for emissions affecting EJ Communities. Of note, SO2 and NOx emissions from power plants have fallen dramatically (93% and 87%, respectively) since an emissions trading program to address acid rain was implemented in 1995. Also, though PM2.5 emissions have fallen almost 40% since 2000, they were still estimated to have caused 13% of US deaths in 2018.

What can we say then about the likely impact of these provisions within the legislation? The table below provides an estimate of the impact should emissions from the above three sources be covered by the SOFA provisions. The 2020 emissions are multiplied by the corresponding fee to yield potential annual revenues of $62 billion, $44 billion and $97 billion for each of the three criteria air pollutants covered.

The EPA has also recently analyzed the value (converted to $2021 per pound, Table 7, page 16) of the health benefit of avoided emissions from these pollutants. The benefits were estimated for each of 17 sources, and their value vary greatly by source in part because the health impact is a function of where the pollution occurs. For this analysis, we averaged the health value across three sources most likely to be covered by the bill: electric generating units, industrial point sources, and refineries.


These health benefit values are listed in the table above, and when multiplied by total emissions, provides the estimated benefit should all US emissions be abated. These values are $328 billion, $90 billion, and $1,173 billion, respectfully.  Not surprisingly, the value of the emission reductions are many multiples of the fees charged.

Though these are only rough estimates of the revenue and benefits from SOFA’s EJ provisions, it is clear that pricing has worked in the past to reduce air pollution, these charges are substantial, and that this approach of making harmful air pollution significantly more expensive will guarantee improved health in EJ communities and generate revenues that can be used to bolster economic growth.

Note: For more information and CCL's overall take on the bill see the entry on the Save Our Future Act here on CCL Community's Carbon Pricing Bills in Congress resource.

* “Est. EJ Emissions” Includes emissions from electric generating units, industrial point sources, and refineries only. This amounts to a very rough estimate of what emissions would be covered by the SOFA, and is almost certainly an overestimate. “SOFA” Fee/lb simply reports the fee specified in the legislative text for the covered co-pollutants. “Emissions X Fee” reports the product of estimated EJ emissions and the Fee in millions of dollars. “Health Benefit/lb” reports the EPA estimated health benefit in $2021 per pound. “Emissions X Benefit” reports the product of the estimated EJ emissions and the reported Health Benefit per pound in millions of 2021 dollars.

Posted by Brett Cease on Aug 18, 2021 3:17 AM America/Los_Angeles

Share this


Recent Posts

September 15, 2021 Signs that carbon pricing could end up in the reconciliation bill continue to be encouraging. The latest indication comes from Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse’s Twitter posts. Sen. Whitehouse, who sits on the Senate Finance Committee currently drafting climate provisions in the budget reconciliation bill,  tweeted  on Friday that ... more
Posted by Brett Cease on CCL Community Bulletin Sep 15, 2021 2:54 PM PDT
September 8, 2021 On Friday, news broke that the Senate Finance Committee is actively considering a price on carbon as part of the budget reconciliation package. Senators are discussing a carbon fee that would start at $15 per ton, escalating over time, and be paired with rebates to households and a border carbon adjustment. Sound familiar? “This is a ... more
Posted by Brett Cease on CCL Community Bulletin Sep 8, 2021 4:07 PM PDT
Citizens’ Climate Radio is a monthly podcast hosted by CCLer Peterson Toscano. Browse all our past episode recaps  here , or listen to past episodes  here , and check out the latest episode in the post below.   In our latest podcast episode, Chantal Bilodeau tells us about  Climate Change Theatre Action  (CCTA) 2021. Founded in 2015, CCTA is a worldwide ... more
Posted by Brett Cease on CCL Community Bulletin Sep 8, 2021 3:58 PM PDT
Each month, Citizens’ Climate Lobby supporters gather locally for a  monthly meeting  where we educate ourselves by listening to a guest speaker. Go to your  local chapter's page  to find out more about your chapter's plans for listening in.   September's Monthly Meeting will take place on Saturday, Sept.11th   and feature a conversation ... more
Posted by Brett Cease on CCL Community Bulletin Sep 8, 2021 2:21 PM PDT